The great debate?


In the narrow world of Brussels politics, high entertainment is looming. On Wednesday, Declan Ganley, founder of anti-treaty group Libertas, will face off with Dany ‘le Rouge’ Cohn-Bendit, co-leader of the Greens in the European Parliament in a debate on Europe. And already everybody’s talking about it.

To some in Brussels, Ganley is the devil himself. Charging around, upsetting the political apple cart with loose talk about the treaty all the while claiming to be pro-European. To others, Ganley, who wants to be an MEP, is bringing a welcome edge to the EU political debate ahead of the European elections.

But still he remains an unknown entity in the EU capital. While most have read about him – the Irish businessman who spearheaded a successful campaign against the Lisbon Treaty resulting in Ireland’s no vote last year – few have heard him speak, let alone debate.

He will be facing one of Brussels’ best known politicians. Cohn-Bendit, of 1968er fame, is strongly pro-European, highly opinionated, and a good debater. Ganley, who only recently made the switch from the boardroom to politics, has yet to show himself to be in the same league.

Still I am looking forward to the meeting. Ganley, I feel, is indeed tapping into a swell of people who feel alienated by Brussels. But I don’t think his one-horse campaign – table-thumping, slogan-filled but ultimately lacking in ideas as it is – is the answer.

At the recent unveiling of Libertas’ Brussels office – in which he harangued journalists like they needed to be converted to his politics – the party’s list of ‘principles’ consisted of a ragbag of ideas including less EU meetings, making MEPs’ expenses public and reducing the Union’s annual budget. There was little of what Libertas stood for and much of what it stood against.

So let the gloves come off on Wednesday – but let it be a debate on substance…

,

  1. #1 by M Geenen on March 30, 2009 - 11:42 pm

    Is there a way to watch the debate online? I’m very interested but am unable to attend…

  2. #2 by Honor Mahony on March 31, 2009 - 5:58 am

    Hi there,
    Actually no, you cannot watch it online. It’s a shame. The organisers said they plan to put it on YouTube, but that will only happen a few days later.

  3. #3 by Damien on April 1, 2009 - 1:36 am

    Hi, I’m looking forward to watching the debate on youtube as promised. Being an Irishman and living in Ireland west, I have watched Mr Ganley’s recent entry into Irish and European political life with much interest. While I welcome his effort to make the European elections more about the EU and move the election campaigns away from what are often 2nd order issues of national interest. I find that he is all rhetoric and very little substance. He very successfully plays up to the popular masses that the EU is nothing but a gravy train stuffed with faceless bureacrats and political elites who fear nothing more than engaging with the joe public on European issues, but beneath it all, he attacks the wrong targets in his efforts, not to mention there are clouds hanging over Libertas’ funding in Ireland and now Poland. And I would take issue with him being accorded the face of the No campaign. Many people voted No for reasons that Libertas did not argue. What is dangerous, is that Mr Ganley appears to have adopted a false sense of legitmacy because the result matched what he was fighting for. National politicans, the media and our Commissioner, Mr McCreevy, have all contributed to this by crediting him the success of achieving a No.

  4. #4 by Honor Mahony on April 1, 2009 - 3:12 pm

    I have just seen that the debate is to be livestreamed here: http://www.dcbn.eu/live/

  5. #5 by Damien on April 1, 2009 - 7:36 pm

    I think the standard of the debate has alot to be desired, very poor in my eyes.

    The ‘great debate’, yeah right. It would have been more appropriate to say the ‘great mudfight’.

  6. #6 by zeleneye on April 2, 2009 - 8:59 am

    Poor and turgid stuff.
    ‘Le rouge’ is a shadow of his former oratory self – although English is about his 4th or 5th language I think…so not so easy.
    Ganley is cringeworthy. He managed to sit their for two hours without answering one question he was asked. His statements verged on vomit-inducing.
    The moderation was appalling to let him get away with it.
    Big debate this was not. Big waste of time it was.

(will not be published)